Why Tasting Notes Matter
Every experienced cigar collector has had this experience: you smoke a cigar once, love it, smoke it again a year later from a different batch, and it tastes completely different. Without notes, you can't know whether the cigar changed, your palate changed, or the storage conditions differed.
Tasting notes are a personal record of your relationship with a cigar over time. They help you identify patterns in what you enjoy — which wrappers resonate, which origins your palate tends toward, which vitolas you find most satisfying. Over time, they become a flavor map that makes it significantly easier to choose new cigars and find new pairings.
What to Note and When
Before Lighting: The Cold Draw
Before you even cut the cigar, examine it. Note the wrapper color and any visible veins or oils. Then cut and draw through it cold. Cold draw flavors are often surprisingly revealing: cedar, cream, earth, cocoa, or dried fruit. These compounds are present before combustion alters them.
First Third: Setting the Baseline
Log the following during the first third:
- Strength: mild, mild-medium, medium, medium-full, full
- Body: thin/light, medium, full/complex
- Primary flavor notes: what are the 2–3 dominant flavors?
- Draw quality: too tight, perfect, slightly loose?
- Burn quality: even, slightly wavy, requires touch-ups?
Second Third: The Transition
Most well-made cigars transition during the second third. Flavors deepen, spice appears or fades, secondary notes emerge. This is often the best part of the cigar. Log what changes and what you notice. A transition from cedar/cream in the first third to chocolate/leather in the second is a sign of a complex, quality blend.
Final Third: The True Character
The final third concentrates the oils and the tobacco's natural flavors. A good cigar finishes well — maybe picking up more sweetness, more complexity, or a memorable lingering note. A poor one gets harsh or bitter. Note the finish and your overall rating.
A Simple Rating System
Multi-dimensional ratings are more useful than a single number. Emberly uses the following dimensions:
- Draw (1–10) — resistance through the cut
- Burn (1–10) — evenness throughout the smoke
- Flavor (1–10) — overall flavor quality and complexity
- Complexity (1–10) — how much the cigar evolves across all three thirds
- Value (1–10) — quality relative to price
This five-dimension framework lets you compare cigars meaningfully over time. A cigar that burns perfectly but tastes one-dimensional scores very differently from one that burns unevenly but delivers extraordinary flavor complexity.
Tools for Tracking Tasting Notes
Notebooks: The analog option. A dedicated cigar journal is tactile and personal. The downside is that it's not searchable, not sortable, and unavailable when you're away from home.
Spreadsheets: Better than nothing, but clunky for mobile use and not designed for cigar-specific fields.
Dedicated apps: The best option for any collection over 20 cigars. Emberly's review interface lets you log all five dimensions plus free-form tasting notes immediately after a session, from your phone. The notes are linked to your humidor entry for that cigar, so you can always see every session's notes alongside the cigar's full profile and aging history.
Log Tasting Notes in Seconds
Emberly's review system lets you log multi-dimensional tasting notes immediately after a session. Linked directly to your humidor and pairing history.
Sign Up Free